Silence is Criminal

Posted by Guest Blogger on January 14th, 2010

Happy new decade! I hope the next ten years bring far more good news around sexual health than the last ten.

To refresh what I have been discussing here:  in November 2008, I had fairly good reason to believe that I, an HIV-positive person, had been sexually assaulted. From that realization, I made several quick decisions that worked for me personally: 1) to shower, 2) to get screened for sexually transmitted infections twice in the year that followed, 3) to advise my assailant (via a third person) within 72 hours on the option of securing preventive medication to reduce the likelihood of HIV transmission. You all who are reading, now discover number 4: not to press criminal charges. Several reasons why.

First of all, I did say I showered, so I did not have a rape kit done. However, as I sat for my physical exam, I already began to think about how to tell (can I just call him) BoyWithNoManners (BWNM) about HIV post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP). You all might think I am a saint for doing so, but this was my logic at the time:  Barring any sort of physical evidence – BWNM continued to deny he did anything wrong while I told a mutual friend to tell him about PEP  – I knew that if he went to the emergency room to get PEP, this in itself was an admission of guilt. This fact was in the back of my mind when I washed the blood from my underwear. No one takes 28 days of HIV meds for fun.

I knew I had the ability to press charges if I wanted to, but it was almost time for finals and I was not going to let BWNM ruin my semester.  Another part of it was that I was afraid. I was afraid that he would press charges against me, saying I consented to what he did and that I did not disclose my HIV status.  As I said before, I did not consent because I could not (BWNM clearly needed to get women drinking to get some).

ethics

The laws in my state of Georgia make the following “reckless conduct” a felony. Disclosure laws are so terribly written that I faced the possibility of going to prison as the person who was assaulted if BWNM convinced a jury that I consented:

“A person who is an HIV infected person who, after obtaining knowledge of being infected with HIV: Knowingly engages in sexual intercourse or performs or submits to any sexual act involving the sex organs of one person and the mouth or anus of another person and the HIV infected person does not disclose to the other person the fact of that infected person’s being an HIV infected person prior to that intercourse or sexual act.” O.C.G.A. § 16-5-60 (c) (1)

Finally, even if I had successfully pressed charges, then what? What was the public health message among young men who think it is a rite of university to take advantage of women who drink alcohol? Would his peers even know or care that he had been sentenced for a crime? There had to be a better way to make a final lesson out of this…

READ PART 1

READ PART 2

This is a guest blog post by Nina Martinez

Nina Martinez, 26, is a public health student at Emory University in Atlanta with a focus in epidemiology. Nina’s premature birth facilitated the need for a blood transfusion that infected her with HIV when she was six weeks old in San Francisco, California.

---
Talk about it
3 Comments...
  1. Banders says:

    WOW I have only read the first 2 parts of this, but Nina, your articles are so powerful and send out graphic messages,

    I personally still think you should have pressed charges, and feel the BWNM lable was a bit mild – perhaps Boy Who Doesnt Deserve Your Honesty would be a (still mild) way to put it.

    But it is a sad reality that you yourself would be putting yourself at risk of prison by simply reporting a rape.

    Great pieces though – I am lookign forward to reading the other 2!

  2. Polly says:

    I really relate to this blog, when i was raped i was so afraid to report it because i didn’t think anyone would believe me, especially since i’d been drinking too. i think so many times people try to make life seem different if you’re positive or negative but we go through the same things – well obviously not to the same degree as you feared going to prison because of what a jury could have determined. but that boy still needed to go to jail. i don’t think rape survivors should be responsible for ensuring that their attacker never hurts another girl, but don’t you have regrets about not pressing chargers? i know i do.
    i really appreciate your blogs, they are powerful but also good to relate on some level. maybe i still have too much anger and have a longer way to go than you do, but your attacker didn’t deserve your kindness, anyway, i believe in karma – he’ll get his one day.
    thanks for sharing

  3. Nina says:

    Polly,
    I completely agree when you say “I think so many times people try to make life seem different if you’re positive or negative but we go through the same things.” We’re all human beings! As one of those, I’m so so sorry that rape happened to you. I suppose I don’t have regrets for not pressing charges because I found a different way to get back at him, in what I hope will be more constructive, far-reaching manner (call it directed karma) than putting him in a cell and throwing away the key. Many people who go to prison commit the crime again, so really how helpful is this? There’s also the fact that I got resolution in a lot less time than in a criminal proceeding, which makes me comfortable with my decision. I am very sure he learned something.

    **He** and others like him should be responsible for ensuring that they do not hurt another woman – again, you’re on point deflecting the responsibility from the victims. We need more programs that focus on males and how they can stop sexual violence (man up!), to go alongside programs for women that talk about ways to minimize sexual assault risk.

    Thank you for reading (and sharing!)
    Nina

---

ADD A COMMENT

* REQUIRED FIELDS

---
---
---
---
Become a guest blogger
Post to Share this on Facebook!
---